In December 2015, Daniel Rushing was 64 and living in Orlando, Florida. He had spent part of that day driving a friend to chemotherapy, and he was taking home an older woman from his church who worked at a 7-Eleven and would otherwise have walked the two miles [1].

Police pulled Rushing over just after he left the convenience store. Officer Shelby Riggs-Hopkins told him he had been driving 42 miles an hour in a 30 mph zone and had failed to come to a complete stop before entering the roadway [1]. Those two traffic violations were the stated reason for the stop.

Rushing handed over his driver's license, and Riggs-Hopkins noticed a concealed-weapons permit attached to it. He confirmed there was a pistol in the car, and she asked him to step outside for her safety. She then asked whether officers could search the vehicle. Rushing said yes, provided he would not be ticketed [1]. Four officers searched the car.

Riggs-Hopkins spotted crystals on the floorboard while the officers went through the car. Rushing watched from outside as they put the white substance through a field testing kit, and the kit indicated methamphetamine [1]. He told them the result had to be wrong. "I've never even smoked a cigarette," he said [1].

The officer showed him the substance, and Rushing recognized it. "That's glaze from a Krispy Kreme doughnut!" he said. "I get one every other Wednesday" [1][2]. He told the officers the crumbs came from that habit. Officers booked him on a charge of possessing methamphetamine while armed with a weapon [1].

Rushing sat in jail for more than 10 hours before he made bail [1]. He called his wife to explain what had happened, and the man waiting behind him for the phone started laughing. "He said, 'This is crazy. I think you got a real good lawsuit here,'" Rushing recalled. Sitting in the cell, he asked himself what he was doing there [1].

Orlando police sent the evidence from the car to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement for a second round of testing. The follow-up work was done by the state rather than by the officers who made the stop [1]. The lab found that the crystals were not a controlled substance, and all charges against Rushing were dropped, including the armed-while-possessing count [1].

The field kit that flagged Rushing's doughnut glaze belongs to a category of inexpensive roadside tests that police departments across the country use to screen for drugs quickly, and those kits leave a lot of room for error [1]. A similar stop happened in Oviedo, northeast of Orlando, where Karlos Cashe was pulled over [1]. Rushing's arrest ended in a $37,500 settlement, reported in October 2017 [1][2][3].


Sources

  1. npr.org
  2. foxnews.com
  3. ideastream.org