In 1998, Fiona B. Hunter and Lloyd Davis published observations in The Auk after five years of studying Adélie penguins on Ross Island, about 800 miles from the South Pole [2][6][8]. The account rested on 10 observations involving at least five different females over four breeding seasons [6][8]. In each case, a female joined a single, unpaired male at his nest site, courtship followed, and the male mounted and copulated with her [6]. After the male dismounted, the female picked up a stone from his nest site and left immediately [6]. Five of the females returned to take a second stone [6].
Adélie penguins live along the Antarctic coast and are one of only four penguin species that nest on the continent itself [1]. During breeding season they need bare, rocky ground, and they build nests from stones and pebbles [1][6][9]. A bird nest is the spot where a bird lays and incubates eggs and raises young [5]. In Antarctic colonies, pebbles are scarce and help raise eggs off the frozen ground [9]. Larger nests are more resistant, so penguin pairs collect as many stones as possible, while single males have more time to gather stones and can become a good source of pebbles [6].
The exchanges took place at the male's nesting site. When extra-pair copulation occurred at the female's nesting site, the male did not take a stone [2]. At the male's site, the female took one or more stones after copulation without aggression from the male [2][8]. The researchers recorded no instance of a male courting a female for pebbles, which suggested the behavior was based on sex [6]. Both males and females steal stones, and thieves are sometimes attacked [2].
Not every observed encounter ended in copulation. Some females solicited courtship from males and then took stones without copulating [2][6][8]. Researchers also observed that some females were not always willing to copulate in order to avoid a fight [2]. The 1998 paper called the trade uneven, since one or two stones for an extra-pair copulation seemed a poor exchange [8]. Hunter later said female penguins probably do not engage in prostitution solely for stones and that they may be copulating for another reason while taking stones as well [2].
The females in the observed cases were already pair-bonded to other males [6]. Adélie penguins are monogamous and breed in large colonies [6]. Studies of animal sexual behavior show that social monogamy does not always mean sexual exclusivity, and paired animals can have extra-pair partners [3]. Hunter suggested the behavior might be a mate choice process that could give a female another male if her current mate died [2]. She also estimated that the number of females doing this was only a few percent [2].
Males may gain genetic benefits from these encounters [2][6]. The study indicated that in most cases of extra-pair copulation the male was successful at inseminating the female, with a low percentage of misses [6]. A male who copulated with a female benefited his progeny when she took a stone from him [2]. Researchers speculated about possible genetic fitness advantages and disadvantages and were not sure the female copulated mainly to obtain a stone [2]. The Adélie observations fit a broader record of animals engaging in sexual activity for exchange of significant materials or social bonding [4].
Pebble presentation also appears in accounts of Adélie courtship. A male may present a pebble to a female, and a pair may bond and mate for life [7]. A popular story that penguins propose with pebbles has little supporting evidence [9]. Males tend to do the bulk of nest building and readily steal from neighbors [9]. The Ross Island observations remain a narrow record: 10 cases, at least five females, and a behavior that Hunter said involved only a few percent of the population [2][6][8].






